For full functionality of this site it is necessary to enable JavaScript. Here are the instructions how to enable JavaScript in your web browser.

(Canvas drawing not supported by your browser.) (Canvas drawing not supported by your browser.)

Change the horizontal view angle:
Change the vertical view angle:
Trajectory position:

← Simpler version

Description:

In this system there is only one space dimension, shown on the vertical axis and labeled in millions of meters (Mm). The time dimension is the horizontal axis and labeled in minutes. The curving line show a cannonball shot straight upwards and then falling back to Earth, ignoring air resistance. At such heights (20 Mm is around 5% of the distance to the moon), the force of gravity drops considerably, down to just 0.57 ms-2 from 9.8 ms-2 at the surface. As a result, the trajectories are no longer parabolas.

The 3D scene is a different way of showing the same graph. We have taken the 2D graph and rolled it up like a sheet of paper, such that the time axis is now wrapped up in a circle. By adding a little bulge at the bottom this surface acquires a very special property: all the free-fall trajectories are now geodesics (straight lines) on this surface. (Imagine a tiny ant walking on the surface. If the ant always walks forwards, never turning left or right, then the path it takes will be a geodesic.)

You can drag the trajectory around using the two circles on the 2D graph. When the cannonball escapes Earth's gravity we color the trajectory red, otherwise when it falls back to Earth we color it blue.

The 3D graph illustrates a key property of general relativity, that inertial objects (objects like cannonballs that are free to fall) move in straight lines through spacetime. Gravity works because the mass of the Earth distorts spacetime, causing the bulge we can see at the bottom. The curvature of the surface steers the geodesics back down to Earth, so to an Earth-based observer it seems like the cannonballs are being pulled towards us by some invisible force.

As the height increases, and the force of gravity decreases, the curvature of the 3D embedding decreases. In the limit it becomes a cylinder, where there is zero gravity. Inertial objects will move along helices if they are moving towards or away from Earth, or will move in circles around the cylinder if they are at rest relative to the Earth.

This 3D embedding was created by Rickard Jonsson in a 2001 paper. Many thanks to Rickard for helping me implement it.

Implementation details:

See code/jonsson_embedding.js for the implementation details of mapping space and time onto the 3D surface. We compute the free-fall trajectories using a formula for the free-fall time from here. The formula is only valid for non-relativistic speeds but that's appropriate in this case. To validate our implementation we compute geodesics for the 3D surface and compare the two. Code for this is available if you are interested.

Code, more details, feedback: https://github.com/timhutton/GravityIsNotAForce